
Tourism Tamasha
January 28, 2007Now it was a very interesting article published in today’s Dawn …
By Mustansar Hussain Tarar
Once upon a time a full-fledged prime minister of Pakistan visited the Northern Areas to hear out the grievances of the populace. Wherever he went the locals complained about a certain glacier which was forcibly occupied by the Indians, thus dividing their families.
The PM was at a loss as to what these people were complaining about, so he asked his assistants to clarify the matter. He was told that they wanted their glacier back. The PM smiled knowingly and said, “Oh this matter of Gulsher missing has been brought to my notice repeatedly and I assure that the government is giving this matter top most priority. We will bring back this Gulsher Khan wherever he is. Don’t you worry about it”.
Khawja Mehrdad, who served as the principal of Government College Skardu, once participated in a high-level meeting in Islamabad chaired by the then federal minister for education. Khawja sahib complained about the lack of education facilities and funds in Skardu. The education minister haughtily replied, “Well the government is fully aware that in Baluchistan there is a lack of educational facilities and we have chalked out a master plan for the uplift of education in that area. Don’t you worry about it.”
“But sir, I am talking about Skardu,” Khawja sahib said sheepishly.
“Well,” the ‘all-knowing minister’ looked at him with contempt, “This Skardu is in Baluchistan, isn?t it??”
Khawja sahib dare not correct him as he did not want to lose his job.
The situation has not changed drastically since then. Our education minister recently mourned about the declining standards of education and to prove his point made fun of our cricket captain Inzamamul Haq’s poor English. I had then humbly suggested that in future our cricket team should be selected from the waiters of five star hotels as they speak excellent English. Because this suggestion was ignored, our cricket team lost the first Test against South Africa.
But it was our prime minister who bowled a real beauty by giving the target of one million tourists for the preset year to the tourist ministry and all concerned are parroting that this target will be met. I am sure this can be easily achieved by the agencies that can abduct a million tourists from all over the world and bring them to Pakistan, forcibly if necessary, and they can be listed as ‘missing persons’.
If this is not feasible, I have another suggestion. All the city and district nazims should be ordered to collect as many people as possible, pack them in hijacked buses and wagons and take them to the next city as tourists. The Karachiwalas should be dispatched to Quetta and Quettawalas can be sent to Lahore. As a matter of fact, whole villages of the feudal areas could be transported to Dadu or Skardu, and this will be called family tourism. And I am sure the target of one million will be easily achieved. For the nazims and district authorities it should not be much of a problem as they have shown their competence in the past by providing these unwilling masses for the public meetings of the ruling parties.
As a chronic tourist I am overjoyed that year 2007 has been declared as a year of tourism. But how are you going to go about it? Holding senseless seminars, tourist melas, pathetic jeep safaris, camel races, Gandhara week and so on and so forth, repeating for the umpteenth time the same old clich-hat Pakistan is the cradle of ancient civilizations? We have deserts, coastlines, mountains, hospitable populace, and if you want to see a madressa, a visit can easily be arranged with a dozen guards to protect you and you can keep those guards for rest of the visit if you care about you dear life.
There was this meeting some time in the past for the promotion of tourism where the officials were parroting the above-mentioned cliches and were sure that every potential tourist in the world is dying to visit Pakistan.
However, my point of view was rather radical: “Gentlemen, if I were an American or European with a pocket full of dollars, I would be an idiot if I headed for Pakistan. There are better beaches in Goa and Sri Lanka where bikinis will not cause a riot, deserts are much larger and scenic in Afghanistan and Iran. Nepal also has the highest mountains in the world and you cannot beat India for this cradle of civilization crap, so how are you going to entice the potential tourist? I maintain that Pakistan has a potential for the domestic tourism, please forget the gora and concentrate on the local kalas.”
The initial attraction for any white tourist is a law-abiding country where he can roam about freely and safely. Here our police chiefs, advocate generals and even the president is not safe. A gora, even if he is not an American roaming around, is ideal for kidnapping. Even the Chinese friends are not spared. Has anybody seen a white tourist having fun in Peshawar or Miramshaha recently? So much for the law and order situation!
The other factor is the attitude of locals towards tourists. It is, I am afraid, utterly hostile with the exception of Hunza and Baltistan. We have not developed a culture of tolerance towards foreigners and, mind you, before the Russian invasion even the Afghans were very liberal in this respect. Indians are masters of this craft and even Iran is much more tolerant than us Pakistanis.
The other day I had the misfortune of watching a PTV discussion programme regarding this so-called tourism year and it was pathetic. One of the participants, Mr Iqbal from Skardu, raised some very relevant objections regarding the government?s policy and the minister for tourism, lording over the discussion not like a lord but lady because she is a lady, got furious and said, “Don?t malign Pakistan.”
As if the politicians had left any maligning for poor Mr Iqbal! When he raised another point that tourists crossing from China into Pakistan had to travel all the way to Islamabad to procure a climbing permit and then go back from where they started and that can?t these permits be issued in Gilgit or Skardu?
The lady said with a broad smile, “The prime minister is considering the proposal.”
Now I know why our prime minister is so busy, he is considering a proposal that instead of Islamabad the climbing permit should be made available in Gilgit or Skardu. Tough decision to make I am sure. I personally know that Mr Iqbal, who is perhaps a member of Northern Areas council, has done much more for the promotion of tourism than the whole ministry, including the minister. However, at the end of programme the minister was very sweet and told the viewers, “These tourism matters were not addressed for the last one hundred years and it seems that we have opened a Pandora’s box. So be patient, give us time to implement our planned policies.”
I could be wrong but as far as my guess goes, Pakistan was created only about 60 years back. Where did these hundred years come from?
I wish the establishment a very happy tourist year and congratulate them for spending millions of rupees for attracting exactly one million tourists to Pakistan ? no more, no less. By the end of this year if I discover a single white tourist freely roaming about in the streets of Pakistan, I will, if I am alive by then, personally go to Islamabad to shake the hand of the minister, if she is still the minister.





